When the Wesleyan Church in Bath Street was built, the Methodist New Connexion took the small chapel in Market Street. This building disappeared many years ago.
The Methodist New Connexion had been the first movement to break with the main body of Wesleyans, shortly after Methodist preacher Alexander Kilham wrote a pamphlet advocating certain radical views in 1795. One of these views was his wish to reform Wesley’s position that Methodists should go to the ParishChurch to partake of the Sacrament of the Lord’s Supper. He suggested instead that people should receive the ordinance of the Lord’s Supper at their own places of worship and from their own ministers.
He also desired that the laity should have a greater say in Methodist Church government.
These proposed reforms didn’t go down too well with the established Wesleyan opinion such that the Wesleyan Conference expelled Kilham in 1796.
A year later, with fellow preacher William Thom, he had formed the first major non-Wesleyan Methodist Church, initially called ‘The New Itinerancy’ but soon to become known as the Methodist New Connexion.
Although expanding quite rapidly in the late 1790’s, the Kilhamites suffered a reverse at Ilkeston.
They made attempts to gain possession of the town’s Wesleyan chapel but were rebuffed, the congregation shouting “Old Methodism for ever! From this day we will double our subscriptions”.
Consequently Ilkeston was viewed as a lost cause by the New Connexion which doesn’t seem to have made a more permanent appearance in Ilkeston until 1873.
In that year it was a very small society in the town, centred on the family of Samuel Hudson, a lacemaker born in Loughborough but trading in Nottingham where he married Elizabeth Ashby in 1856. With five sons the couple moved from Ortzen Street in Nottingham to Ilkeston about 1866/67. The youngest son, Samuel junior, died in Ilkeston in December 1867 and the 1871 census shows the family at 14 North Street, where Samuel is described as ‘lacemaker and (misleadingly?) Primitive Methodist local preacher’.
Two years later, with his wife, two of his sons John and Edwin, and a few others, Samuel formed a Methodist New Connexion meeting group which grew slowly over the next few months until, in November 1873 the New Connexion bought the Market Street Chapel, vacated by the Old Wesleyans, for £280.
In 1889 the Connexion moved to new premises in Stamford Street. The local press reported on this new chapel. The congregation members decided to pull down the old chapel and use the material in the building the new chapel, saving an estimated £300 in building costs, which, with the purchase of the land from the Duke of Rutland, were thought to total nearly £900. Temporarily the vestry attached to the existing chapel would be employed for worship.
Gothic in design, with a nave 60 feet by 24 feet, the new structure was to accommodate 560 people. Inside, between the aisles and the nave, iron columns would support pressed brick arches, with a raised choir gallery behind the rostrum, with four classrooms beneath and to the rear. At the front will be a five-light lancet window, a small stone tower above, and a roof of open timber work. Main entrances will be to the right and left of the frontage. Its architect was Abraham Harrison Goodall of Nottingham and its builders Frederick Shaw and Son, based in Rutland Street.
The Stamford Street premises closed as a church in 1963 to be reincarnated as a car showroom.